Still, the ambiguously partial praise i offer here is not just for the whig interpretation of history but also for the unitalicized and lowercased whig interpretations of history that the book criticizes. Basically, what the whig theory of history says is that history is an inevitable march upward into the light. And the term whig interpretation has been applied to both the latter and to all types of present minded history. The matter is historical and political, it deals with knowledge and epistemology, culture and philosophy. Apr 21, 2020 quoted in mcintire, herbert butterfield, historian as dissenter, pp. Butterfields victory and defeat, encounter 66 1986, 1925. The history of charlemagne ends about 60% of the way through this book, and is much thinner than i had expected.
Ashplant, whig history and presentcentred history, the historical journal, 31 1988. Butterfields main claim now seems uncontentious essentially he argues against a teleological interpretation of history which sees it as forever approaching an endpoint our modern liberal world. You requested books with titles starting with a history of the whig party, or some of its main features. Trevor colbourn very interesting book the lamp of experience. Presentcentred history and the problem of historical. One small matter that struck me was the notion of whig history. Wellcome unit for the history of medicine, cambridge. It takes its name from the british whigs, advocates of the power of parliament, who opposed the tories, advocates of the power of the king and the aristocracy. When the victorians asked themselves how they had come to live in such an apparently perfect society, they looked for an explanation to the history of england. The history of political parties simple book production. The importance of that essay is not just that it attained the status of a classic in butterfields own lifetime, and has continued to be reprinted for over fifty years.
Alongside the democratic party, it was one of the two major parties in the united states during the late 1830s, the 1840s, and the early 1850s, part of the second party system. In the beginning, soon after the us constitution was adopted, politics were pretty nonexistent. It was the cambridge historian her bert butterfield who described and condemned what. Butterfields critique of the whig interpretation springerlink. Whig history and presentcentred history adrian wilson t. Or whig history in the evils of contemporary dance, science.
The whig vision of history derived from the commonlaw claim of. In response to these paradoxes scholars reach for a short cut through that maze of interactions by which the past was turned into our present 25. Whig history tells a tale that is centered in and constantly points to the present. I learn about historical writing jane takes on history. Back to elton, herbert butterfield and the study of history, 729. Then you can start reading kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer no kindle device required. Its a short read, and will give you a solid understanding of what you should be looking for.
The whig interpretation of history herbert butterfield. Eye on the presentthe whig history of science steven weinberg it was the cambridge historian herbert butter. Whig history was, in short, an extremely biassed view of the past. The term is often applied generally and pejoratively to histories that present. In defence of a present centred history of science article in studies in history and philosophy of science part a. See wilson and ashplant, whig history and presentcentred history, pp. In the whig view, english history was the story of a struggle for the recovery of political and religious liberty which, they held, had been lost at the time of the norman conquest. I use the book as the base for a discussion of whig history and why it is so dangerous when writing about science. Ashplant, whig history and present centred history, the historical journal, 30, i 1988, 116. The approach was announced and explained in rogers book client centred therapy. It was the cambridge historian herbert butterfield who described and condemned what he called the whig interpretation of history. Whig history could first be said to have originated during the 19th century in histories of the english civil war.
It is part and parcel of the whig interpretation of history that it studies the past with reference to the present. Whig history or whig historiography is an approach to historiography that presents the past as an inevitable progression towards ever greater liberty and enlightenment, culminating in modern forms of liberal democracy and constitutional monarchy in general, whig historians emphasize the rise of constitutional government, personal freedoms and scientific progress. In the decades since that book was originally published, butterfields designation has been extended far beyond its original domain of political and religious history. What differentiates whig history from more genuine historical work by which he means the attempt to understand the coherence of the past on its own terms, says butterfield, is that this present centeredness causes the historian to overlook the complex and. The use of the term evidence here was, of course, inadequate. The whig interpretation of history by herbert butterfield. We have not dealt with halls more specific argument, that in the particular field of the history of science, butterfields historiographic strictures simply cannot be followed, and that whiggism is unavoidable. Life story books lsb can provide a holistic view of older adults, promote relationship centred care and enhance person centred care. I suggest you pick up a copy of herbert butterfields the whig interpretation of history, the book that first coined the term. Eye on the presentthe whig history of science from the december 17, 2015 issue. While the history books may tell us that the civil war centered around a valiant effort to give rights to slaves of african descent, in truth, this war was all about economics. While acknowledging that insight, two historians then criticized butterfield himself for present centredness they spelled it that way, being british. May 12, 2008 for more detail, i highly recommend the book. Eighty years have passed since a young cambridge don named herbert butterfield published in 1931 a slender volume entitled the whig interpretation of history.
Do you think it was inevitable that the usa would one day have a nonwhite president. Use of life story books in a continuing care setting. This book is a critical essay on the whig interpretation of history according to the theory standing behind, i. History is an umbrella term that relates to past events as well as the memory, discovery, collection, organization, presentation, and interpretation of information about these events.
Ashplant, whig history and present centered history, historical journal 31 1988, 116, who see the solution in the way we select sources. The acme of whig history is macaulay with his massive book the history of england five volumes from 1848 to 1861 which centred around the events of the year1688. Key, whig interpretation of history, based on my article in a global encyclopedia of historical writing, ed. Less a book than a lengthy essay, the whig interpretation of. Present centred history 255 greater individualism in the gay indifference of the prolific fathers of the ancien r6gime. It was a sort of subset of the historicism paradigm, however many of the whig ideas persisted well into the structuralist age from c. Whig history, crudely, is writing about the past from the perspective of history s winners. Whig history or whig historiography is an approach to historiography that presents the past as. In a book with that title, the young butterfield in 1931 declared that the study of. With the election of the first whig presidential administration in the partys history, clay and his allies prepared to pass ambitious domestic policies such as the restoration of the national bank, the distribution of federal land sales revenue to the states, a national bankruptcy law, and increased tariff rates. Ashplant school of humanities and social sciences, liverpool polytechnic of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the whig interpretation of history the importance of that. The seminal work in the denunciation of whig history is the whig interpretation of history, published by herbert butterfield in 1931. Its still dominant despite criticisms in the 1930s and 40s.
The whig theory of history began in the early to mid19th century, and it has taken over. We cling to a certain organization of historical knowledge which amounts to a whig interpretation of history, and all our deference to research brings us only to admit that this needs. Back to 12 the quote ran, darwin was accused of taking mind out of the universe. Whig history and presentcentred history adrian wilson wellcome unit for the history of medicine, cambridge and t. Whig history and present centred history adrian wilson wellcome unit for the history of medicine, cambridge and t. Whig history was, in short, an extremely biased view of the past.
School of humanities and social sciences, liverpool polytechnic. During herbert butterfields lifetime, most historians were certain that the whig interpretation of history 1973 1931 had finished once and for all with the interpretation of history as the ratification if not the glorification of the present butterfield, 1973 1931, p. In a book with that title, the young butterfield in 1931 declared that the study of the past with one eye, so to speak, upon the present is the source of all sins and sophistries in. With a hurried glance at the formation of parties in the united states, and the outlines of the history of the principal parties in the country to the present time, etc. Gove, schama and other advocates of the new britain centred narrative are all essentially proponents of the whig interpretation of history, a theory exploded by professional historians more than half a century ago under the influence of herbert butterfield. To the editors steven weinberg suggests, in eye on the presentthe whig history of science nyr, december 17, 2015, that historians of science may be permitted to view the past in terms of modern knowledge called whig history, whereas others may not. Everyone interested in history should read this very short book. The british historian herbert butterfield coined the term whig history in his short but influential book the whig interpretation of history 1931. Its a phrase ive encountered before and understood to mean a kind of triumphalist point of view in the writing of history. Conspiracy theories abounded in 19thcentury american politics rumors of secret alliances, bank deals, and doublecrossings were rampant in early american elections. In addition, youll find great book recommendations that may be of interest to you based on your search and purchase history, as well as the most wished for and most gifted books. The republican party, often called the gop short for grand old party is one of two major political parties in the united states.
Of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the whig interpretation of history. Like the professional historians he spoke to, we are content to displaythe ivorytower syndrome, writing scholarly treatises only forone another, disdaining both the general reader and our naturalreadership, scientists. Butterfield published the whig interpretation of history in 1931. The republican party was founded as an antislavery platform. Although butterfields generation of historians learned to be suspicious of stirring narratives that played fast and loose with. Presentcentred history and the problem of historical knowledge. Conspiracy theories abounded in 19thcentury american. Reviews of butterfields books are fully listed in sewell, k. It sees history as always progressing toward the abolition of arbitrary differences between people. Scholars who write about history are called historians. Butterfields book on the whig interpretation marked the emergence of a negative concept in.
Since the mid1970s, the labels whig or whiggish have been. Ashplant school of humanities and social sciences, liverpool polytechnic of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the whig interpretation of history the importance of that essay is not. Of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the whig interpretation of history the importance of that essay is not. Pdf is the history of science essentially whiggish. Eye on the presentthe whig history of science by steven. The whig narrative is the popular version of whig history. Adrian wilson, the infancy of the history of childhood. Whig history presents the past as an inevitable progression towards ever greater liberty and enlightenment, culminating in modern forms of liberal democracy and constitutional monarchy. It really seems like a critique, or insult to the author when he is accused of whig history. In which john green teaches you where american politicians come from. The whig interpretation of history and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. If the high point of the whig interpretation is the victorian historians such as macaulay and the early twentieth century historians like his nephew george macaulay trevelyan, the origins lie much further back, in the lateseventeenth century admittedly, the debate has centered on later wih. What exactly this curious phrase meant was not immediately clear, since it had never before appeared in print. Whig history and presentcentred history the historical journal.
It creates a history centered around the actors whom the historian. Whig and tory, members of two opposing political parties or factions in england, particularly during the 18th century. In particular, he convincingly relates aspects of the attack on whig history to the separation of history from law in the british universities at the end of the nineteenth century and to the concomitant revolt against the anachronisms arising from the search for precedents for present practices and institutions. Is whig history considered to be bad history, or are there authors who are proud of doing whig history and explicitly propagate it. The importance of that essay is not just that it attained the status of a classic in butterfields own lifetime, and has. Though whig historians are no longer in the ascendency, this is a good antidote for reading history as if it were a story that leads to your particular view of the present. Butterfield thought it ridiculous that history should glorify the present and eulogise the past. The first party system is a model of american politics used by political scientists and historians to periodize the political party system existing in the united states between roughly 1792 and 1824. Different kinds of whig history are wrong or right for different kinds of reasons which planks of the. An attempt to oflfer a way out of the controversy is in a.
Originally whig and tory were terms of abuse introduced in 1679 during the heated struggle over the bill to exclude james. Search the worlds most comprehensive index of fulltext books. Antifederalist debates, it featured two national parties competing for control of the presidency, congress, and. It takes its name from the british whigs, advocates of the power of parliament, who opposed the tories, advocates of the power of the king.
The british historian herbert butterfield coined the term in his small but influential book the whig interpretation of history 1931. The whig narrative and american christianity james r. Whig history and presentcentred history cambridge university. Whig history and presentcentred history adrian wilson. Were you pleased when president obama won the us election. Thinking about presentism from a historians perspective. Whig history and presentcentred history the historical. In a book with that title, the young butterfield in 1931 declared that the study of the past with one eye, so to speak, upon the present. An afterword by james elkins gives a critique of the present project.
Sir herbert butterfield was regius professor of history and vicechancellor of the university of cambridge. Here was a study which resembled classical whig history in offering a broad, synthetic sweep spanning several centuries but which was diametrically opposed to whig history in its animating value judgment. The influence of the present in the writing of history. What does it mean to have a whiggish view of history. Whig history and the intellectual origins of the american revolution explored the impact whig historians montesquieu, locke, sidney, rapin, burgh, gordon, trenchard, etc.
Whig partisan view of the english constitution and the whig view of history which dominated british historiography in the victorian era. Even though butterfield disputed the whig version of history, they say, he remained to a great extent a prisoner of the very tradition he sought to challenge. It is a just the facts biography thatto a faultomits the legends and chivalric hyperbole often heaped upon this king. By the mid1800s, the whig party was practically nonexistent, and former whigs and democrats joined. The frustrated historians short cutswhat we will call research compromisesare drawn from the present and imposed on the past. Herbert butterfield 19001979 as a christian historian. Sep 01, 2012 still, the ambiguously partial praise i offer here is not just for the whig interpretation of history but also for the unitalicized and lowercased whig interpretations of history that the book criticizes. Ashplant school of humanities and social sciences, liverpool polytechnic of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most influential by far was the whig interpretation of history. The whig party was a political party active in the middle of the 19th century in the united states. Part of the studies in modern history book series smh. Of the many books written by the late herbert butterfield, the most in. Etudes galileennes in the field of the history of science. In general, whig historians stress the rise of constitutional government, personal freedoms and scientific progress.
781 598 333 1498 1346 1273 581 925 116 1204 5 1228 972 500 1472 1038 877 1445 445 940 1371 712 890 1000 1198 1468 1336 44 196 148 270 931 1250 840